Moving Comparison

Piece of Cake Moving & Storage vs Atlas Van Lines

By Daniel Harper, Senior Editor, Moving Costs · Reviewed by Melissa Grant, Pricing & Estimates Reviewer · Last updated May 2026

At-a-glance

On our weighted score, Piece of Cake Moving & Storage takes the edge (4.6/5). That said, Piece of Cake Moving & Storage is the better pick for manhattan high-rise moves with coi, while Atlas Van Lines wins for corporate and government relocations. Always get binding estimates from both before booking.

Compare written estimates from both

Get matched with FMCSA-licensed movers — typically 3–4 quotes within one business day.

Get free quotes

Side-by-side

CategoryPiece of Cake Moving & StorageAtlas Van Lines
USDOTVerify on FMCSA125550
MC #Verify on FMCSA79658
BBB ratingA+A+
Founded20141948
HeadquartersNew York, NYEvansville, IN
CoverageRegionalAll 50 states
ServicesLocal, Long-distance, Packing, StorageLong-distance, International, Packing, Storage, Corporate
2BR estimate$700–$2,700$3,000–$7,200
Customer rating4.6 / 54.2 / 5

Piece of Cake Moving & Storage

Specializes in NYC high-rise and walk-up moves with strong building-management relationships. Online booking and binding flat-rate quotes are unusual in the local market.

USDOT
Verify on FMCSA
BBB
A+
Pros
  • Best for manhattan high-rise moves with coi.
  • Regional coverage; founded 2014.
  • BBB rating: A+.
Watch out
  • Premium pricing relative to budget local movers.
Read full Piece of Cake Moving & Storage review →

Atlas Van Lines

Atlas runs a federated agent network with strong corporate relocation operations. Customer experience tracks closely to which local agent handles your shipment, which is worth checking before signing.

USDOT
125550
BBB
A+
Pros
  • Best for corporate and government relocations.
  • All 50 states coverage; founded 1948.
  • BBB rating: A+.
Watch out
  • Local availability depends heavily on the specific Atlas agent in your region — quality can vary between markets.
Read full Atlas Van Lines review →
Piece of Cake Moving & Storage
Best for

Manhattan high-rise moves with COI

Not ideal for

Premium pricing relative to budget local movers.

Atlas Van Lines
Best for

Corporate and government relocations

Not ideal for

Local availability depends heavily on the specific Atlas agent in your region — quality can vary between markets.

Compare Piece of Cake Moving & Storage and Atlas Van Lines — and a few alternatives

We match you with FMCSA-licensed movers serving your route. No obligation; written estimates only.

Step 1 of 3 · Locations

Where are you moving?

Get matched with up to 4 licensed movers in 60 seconds.

ZIP or City

.

ZIP or City

.

Free · No obligation · Licensed FMCSA-verified movers

Frequently asked questions

Is Piece of Cake Moving & Storage or Atlas Van Lines better in 2026?
On weighted score, Piece of Cake Moving & Storage edges ahead, but the right pick depends on your specific move. Piece of Cake Moving & Storage is best for manhattan high-rise moves with coi; Atlas Van Lines is best for corporate and government relocations. Get binding-not-to-exceed estimates from both before deciding.
How do Piece of Cake Moving & Storage and Atlas Van Lines compare on price?
For a typical 2-bedroom interstate move, Piece of Cake Moving & Storage estimates land around $700–$2,700 and Atlas Van Lines estimates land around $3,000–$7,200. Actual quotes depend on weight, distance, service level, date, and availability.
Are Piece of Cake Moving & Storage and Atlas Van Lines both FMCSA-licensed?
Yes. Piece of Cake Moving & Storage operates under USDOT Verify on FMCSA and Atlas Van Lines operates under USDOT 125550. Always verify the specific entity quoting your move on FMCSA SAFER before signing an estimate.
Does Piece of Cake Moving & Storage or Atlas Van Lines have a better BBB rating?
Piece of Cake Moving & Storage carries a A+ BBB profile and Atlas Van Lines carries a A+. Local agent or franchise ratings can differ from the parent profile, so check the agent that will actually handle your move.
What estimate type should I ask for?
For interstate moves, ask for a binding or binding-not-to-exceed estimate after an in-home or video survey. Sight-unseen non-binding interstate quotes are not reliable and tend to grow on delivery day.

Ready to compare licensed movers?

Get free, no-obligation written estimates from FMCSA-licensed movers serving your route.

Step 1 of 3 · Locations

Where are you moving?

Get matched with up to 4 licensed movers in 60 seconds.

ZIP or City

.

ZIP or City

.

Free · No obligation · Licensed FMCSA-verified movers

Keep researching